Back to Directory

Did Obama Weaponize the IRS?

The IRS really did single out groups by name. Whether the White House ordered it is a separate question — and every body that investigated answered it the same way.
Teach It In Context The Obama Years — U.S. History II, Strand 6
Open the lesson

What Actually Happened

In January 2010 the Supreme Court decided Citizens United, and money in elections changed shape. Applications for 501(c)(4) status — the 'social welfare' category that lets an organization spend on politics without disclosing its donors — jumped. In the IRS office in Cincinnati that processed them, screeners started pulling aside applications that looked political. They did it by reading the organization's name and its stated goals rather than its actual activity, and they kept lists of flagged words titled 'Be On the Look Out.'

The lists grew. 'Tea Party.' 'Patriots.' '9/12.' 'Educating on the Constitution.' Later came 'Occupy,' 'ACORN successors,' 'medical marijuana,' and progressive names as well. Files pulled this way sat for months; some sat for more than three years. Groups were asked for their donor lists, the books they were reading, and details of protests they had planned — requests the IRS's own watchdog later called unnecessary to decide tax status.

On May 10, 2013, Lois Lerner, who ran the Exempt Organizations division, answered a question at an American Bar Association conference that had been arranged in advance, and apologized. Four days later the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration published an audit with a blunt title: 'Inappropriate Criteria Were Used to Identify Tax-Exempt Applications for Review.' The IRS had used the wrong criteria. The watchdog did not find that the employees involved were politically motivated.

Then the file went to everyone else: the FBI, the Justice Department, two Senate committees, and House oversight staff. A wider inspector general review in 2017 found that keyword screening had been used for both conservative and liberal groups, and traced the practice back to 2004 — before Barack Obama was elected. In October 2017 the IRS settled two lawsuits and apologized in a court filing.

The honest summary is uncomfortable for both camps. Something real and improper happened at the Internal Revenue Service, and the agency said so itself. Nothing in the record shows the president or the White House ordering it. Those are two different findings, and this page keeps them apart.

Work Cited

Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration, 'Inappropriate Criteria Were Used to Identify Tax-Exempt Applications for Review,' Audit #201210022, Reference No. 2013-10-053 (May 14, 2013). Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration, follow-up letter to Rep. Sander Levin (June 26, 2013). U.S. Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, 'IRS and TIGTA Management Failures Related to 501(c)(4) Applicants Engaged in Campaign Activity' (Sept. 2014), with Additional and Minority Views. U.S. Senate Committee on Finance, bipartisan report on 501(c)(4) applications (2015). U.S. Department of Justice, letter to Congress closing the criminal investigation (Oct. 23, 2015). Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration, review of 501(c)(4) screening, September 2017 (reported by NPR, Oct. 5, 2017). Consent order, Linchpins of Liberty v. United States (Oct. 2017); settlement, NorCal Tea Party Patriots v. IRS. House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, staff report (Dec. 2014). 'The Fake Story About the IRS Commissioner and the White House,' The Atlantic (May 31, 2013).

What Each Investigation Found

  • Treasury Inspector General, May 2013: The IRS used inappropriate criteria — names and policy positions instead of activity — on 298 applications flagged as of May 31, 2012. 96 of them had 'Tea Party,' '9/12,' or 'Patriots' in the name; the other 202 did not. The office did not classify groups by ideology, and reported no evidence of political motivation by the employees involved.
  • Inspector General follow-up, June 2013: Asked why the first report never mentioned liberal groups, the office went back and found 6 applications with 'progress' or 'progressive' in the name inside the same 298. It also reported a difference in rate: 100% of applications with 'Tea Party,' 'Patriots,' or '9/12' in the name were pulled for review, against about 30% of those with 'progress' or 'progressive.'
  • House Ways and Means staff analysis, 2013: Reviewing the same 298 files, committee staff counted 248 that appeared right-leaning, 29 that appeared left-leaning, and 21 that could not be classified.
  • Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, September 2014: After nearly 800,000 pages of documents and interviews with IRS and watchdog employees, the majority found inappropriate criteria, burdensome questions, and long delays that hit both conservative and liberal groups, and no evidence that the White House or Treasury directed the IRS. Republican members filed dissenting views arguing the majority minimized the bias against conservative groups.
  • Senate Finance Committee, 2015: A bipartisan report, built on 1.5 million pages and 32 witness interviews, found no evidence of a directive to apply political bias and no evidence of White House or Treasury involvement in how applications were handled.
  • FBI, January 2014: Director James Comey said the criminal probe had found no evidence of 'enemy hunting' of the kind suspected, while the investigation continued.
  • Justice Department, October 23, 2015: Closed the criminal investigation with no charges. The letter described 'substantial evidence of mismanagement, poor judgment and institutional inertia leading to the belief by many tax-exempt applicants that the IRS targeted them based on their political viewpoints. But poor management is not a crime.' It also found no obstruction of justice.
  • Inspector General, September 2017: A broader review found keyword screening used for both conservative and liberal groups, and traced the practice to 2004 rather than 2010.
  • Court settlements, October 2017: The IRS settled Linchpins of Liberty (41 groups) and NorCal Tea Party Patriots (428 groups). The consent order admits that applications were screened by name or policy position, subjected to 'heightened scrutiny and inordinate delays,' and asked for information its own watchdog found unnecessary — and states, 'For such treatment, the IRS expresses its sincere apology.' The NorCal case also included a financial payment, reported in the press at roughly $3.5 million; the government did not announce an amount.

“They used names like Tea Party or Patriots and they selected cases simply because those applications had those names in the title. That was wrong, that was absolutely incorrect, insensitive, and inappropriate.”

Lois Lerner, IRS Exempt Organizations director, American Bar Association conference, May 10, 2013

Four Claims, Four Verdicts

Claim 1 — The IRS used political criteria to decide who got extra scrutiny

True. Its own inspector general found the criteria were wrong, and in 2017 the agency apologized in a court filing for screening applications by name and policy position.

Claim 2 — Conservative groups carried most of the burden

True. Every application with 'Tea Party,' 'Patriots,' or '9/12' in its name was flagged, against roughly 30% of 'progressive' names. Committee staff counted 248 right-leaning files out of the same 298, and delays ran into years.

Claim 3 — Obama ordered it, or the White House ran it

Not supported. The inspector general (twice), the Senate's own investigation, the FBI, and the Justice Department all looked for direction from the White House or Treasury and found none. The commissioner during the targeting was a George W. Bush appointee, and the keyword practice reaches back before Obama took office.

Claim 4 — Nothing really happened and the whole thing was manufactured

False. The case was opened by the IRS's own watchdog, the agency apologized, and it paid a settlement. The story became public because an IRS official said it out loud at a conference.

Why Reasonable People Still Doubt the Official Answer

Congress was told it was not happening: Between November 2011 and June 2012 the IRS sent five separate responses to congressional questions without mentioning the screening. On March 22, 2012, Commissioner Douglas Shulman testified, 'There is absolutely no targeting.' Oversight only works if the answers are true.
The disclosure was staged: Lerner's apology came in answer to a question arranged in advance, days before the audit became public, and acting commissioner Steven Miller later told Congress he had discussed with her how the news would come out. Staged disclosure reads as damage control, not candor.
The lost emails: Lerner's hard drive crashed in 2011 and the IRS said years of her email could not be recovered. The Justice Department later said it found no evidence of intentional destruction — but a gap in the record cannot be filled in afterward.
A number that traveled without its context: Commentators reported that Shulman visited the White House 157 times, more than any cabinet member. The logs actually recorded 157 times he was cleared to attend, mostly the regular health-care-reform meetings, and few show him entering. The number was repeated far more often than the explanation.
The questions themselves: Donor lists, reading lists, and questions about planned protests chill a small organization even when the application is eventually approved. A group that spent three years proving it was not a political committee has a reasonable complaint no matter what the file says about motive.

Why This Case Is Worth Teaching

A 501(c)(4) application is a request for permission — permission to be treated as a social welfare group, keep donors private, and still spend on politics. When the office that grants that permission looks at your name instead of your activity, real power has been used, whether or not anyone in Washington intended it. That half of the story is documented, admitted, and settled. It is not a narrative.

The other half is the claim that a president turned the tax agency against his opponents. Every body that investigated looked for that and came back empty-handed: the IRS's own inspector general, a Senate subcommittee run by the opposition's critics and its allies, a bipartisan Senate finance report, the FBI, and a Justice Department that had changed parties by the time it closed the file. The 2017 review pushed the practice back to 2004, which makes 'the Obama IRS' a hard label to defend.

Both sentences are true at once, and that is the lesson. 'The IRS did something wrong' and 'the president weaponized the IRS' are different claims, with different evidence, and one does not follow from the other. The skill this case teaches is holding them apart — noticing when a real abuse gets inflated into a conspiracy, and when a conspiracy gets used to wave away a real abuse. Students meet both moves constantly, in both directions.

Classroom Inquiry: Essential Questions

What is the difference between a bad rule, a bad manager, and a political weapon? Which one does the evidence in this file actually support?
Every investigation found mismanagement and no political motive. Why might a group that waited three years for approval not find that answer satisfying?
The commissioner during the targeting was appointed by George W. Bush, and the keyword lists reach back to 2004. What does that do to the claim that this was an Obama operation, and what does it leave unexplained?
How did the '157 White House visits' number spread faster than the correction? Find a current example of the same pattern and trace it back to its original source.
The IRS apologized and paid a settlement. Does an apology settle a constitutional question, or only a legal one?
If you were writing the rule for which applications get extra scrutiny, what would you base it on — and how would you keep that rule from becoming a weapon?

© 2024 7th Grade Digital Literacy Class | Images from Wikimedia Commons

Support Our Historical Research

Help us continue providing high-quality resources for understanding complex historical narratives.

Contact Us