Skip to main content
Back to Lesson Plans
Active Lesson Plan

The Obama Years: The Great Recession, the Affordable Care Act & a Changing America

U.S. II Strand 6 | Standard 6.3 — The 2008 collapse, the first Black president, and the hard question of how much one president can actually change.
Introduction

Lesson Overview

Grade Level: 11th Grade

Subject
U.S. History II
Utah Standard
U.S. II Standard 6.3 (Contemporary Issues)
Essential Question

How much can one president actually change — and what stops a president from changing it?

Objectives:

Students will explain the economic crisis Barack Obama inherited and evaluate the choices available to him.

Students will trace the fight over the Affordable Care Act from proposal to law to court challenge.

Students will assess the gap between a presidential campaign promise and an outcome, naming who or what stood in the way.

TimeTwo 50-minute class periods

Utah State Standards Alignment

Day 2 What He Could and Could Not Do
Hook (10 min) Ask: Should the government require you to buy something? Take a quick anonymous vote, then reveal that this exact question reached the Supreme Court in 2012.
Mini-Lesson (20 min)
1. The Affordable Care Act, signed March 23, 2010, after more than a year of negotiation with no Republican votes in either chamber. Its main pieces an individual requirement to carry insurance, online marketplaces with subsidies, protections for people with pre-existing conditions, and an expansion of Medicaid. The Supreme Court made the Medicaid expansion optional in 2012. About 20 million more people had coverage by 2016, and the uninsured rate fell from roughly 16% to roughly 9%.
2. The backlash. The Tea Party movement formed in 2009. Republicans ran on repeal, won the House in 2010, voted to repeal dozens of times, and shut the government down over it in 2013. A president signing a law is the middle of the story, not the end.
3. The world. The raid that killed Osama bin Laden (May 2011). The combat mission in Iraq ended in December 2011. The Iran nuclear deal (2015). The Paris climate agreement (2015). Relations with Cuba restored. He also expanded drone strikes and targeted killing — a continuity with the Bush years that surprised many of his own supporters.
4. Race in the open. His March 2008 speech in Philadelphia on race. The killing of Trayvon Martin in 2012 and his "if I had a son" remark. The movement that became Black Lives Matter, which began in 2013. Obergefell v. Hodges (2015) made same-sex marriage legal nationwide.
5. What he could not do. After Sandy Hook (2012), gun legislation failed in the Senate in 2013 with 54 votes — short of the 60 needed. Guantanamo stayed open. Immigration reform died in the House, so he used executive action instead (DACA, 2012), which later presidents fought over in court.
Student Activity (20 min) "Promise vs. outcome." Give each group one campaign promise — close Guantanamo, pass gun background checks, pass immigration reform, end the wars, cut the deficit in half. Students grade each promise A through F and must name who or what blocked it: Congress, the courts, the other party, reality, or the president himself.
1
Phase 01

Standards Alignment

U.S. II Standard 6.3: Students will analyze contemporary issues in the United States — including the rise of terrorism, the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, immigration debates, economic inequality, and challenges to democratic institutions.

Students will evaluate the domestic and foreign policy decisions of a modern presidency using evidence, and explain how separated institutions share and check power.

2
Phase 02

Part 1 - Walking Into a Collapse

Day 1: The Crisis and the First Hundred Days

Hook (10 min): Put two numbers on the board: 5.0% (unemployment, January 2008) and 10.0% (unemployment, October 2009). Ask: If you walked into the Oval Office in January 2009 and saw that chart, what would you do first? Vote on the options below before you know what he actually chose.

Mini-Lesson (20 min):

1. The election. Obama won 365 electoral votes to 173 and about 69.5 million votes. He became the first Black president of the United States. Turnout was the highest in decades.

2. What he inherited. Two wars, a banking system near collapse, an auto industry running out of cash, and unemployment at 7.8% and rising — the worst situation of any incoming president since 1933.

3. The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, signed February 2009, $787 billion: tax cuts, aid to state governments, road and bridge money, and at the time the largest clean-energy investment in U.S. history. Economists still argue about whether it was too small — a memo by two of his own economists had argued for more.

4. The auto rescue. GM and Chrysler were restructured through bankruptcy with federal money. The industry added jobs within a few years, but the politics were brutal — opponents called it picking winners and losers.

5. Dodd-Frank (2010) created a consumer protection agency, required stress tests for big banks, and limited some risky trading.

Student Activity (15 min): Four corners. Label the room: (A) huge stimulus, (B) cut spending to protect the debt, (C) do nothing and let the market clear, (D) nationalize the banks. Students move to a corner and defend their choice using only the unemployment number and the federal deficit. Then reveal what he did and ask who wants to move.

3
Phase 03

Exit Ticket & Discussion

Exit Ticket (10 min): Which was more powerful in Obama's presidency — what he did or what he could not do? Give one example of each with evidence.

Discussion Questions:

His party lost 63 House seats in 2010. How does one election reshape what any president can accomplish?

Should a president use executive action when Congress refuses to act? Compare how you feel about it under Obama, Trump, and Biden. Did your standard stay the same?

"Yes we can" invited people to expect a lot. Is a hopeful campaign promise a strength of democracy or a trap for it?

The uninsured rate fell sharply, and yet the law remained politically toxic for a decade. Can a policy work and still be a political failure?

Extension: Chart the uninsured rate from 2008 to 2022 and mark the ACA, the mandate's repeal in 2017, and the pandemic-era Medicaid changes. Ask what the chart leaves out that people actually felt.

Lesson Finale

Exit Ticket

Primary Sources:

Obama, speech on race, Philadelphia (March 18, 2008)

American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (2009), summary of provisions

President's Economic Recovery Advisory Board memo on stimulus size (2009)

Affordable Care Act (2010), key sections

NFIB v. Sebelius (2012), majority opinion excerpts

Obama, remarks on Trayvon Martin (July 19, 2013)

Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (2015), summary

Documentaries:

"The Divided States of America" (Frontline, PBS)

"Obama's Deal" (Frontline, PBS) — the health care fight

"The Retirement Gamble" (Frontline, PBS)

Books:

Michael Grunwald, The New New Deal

David Remnick, The Bridge

Ta-Nehisi Coates, "My President Was Black" (The Atlantic, 2017)

© 2024 The History Education Foundation | Images from Wikimedia Commons

Playing The Obama Years: The Great Recession, the Affordable Care Act & a Changing America
0:00

Support Our Historical Research

Help us continue providing high-quality resources for understanding key historical concepts.

Contact Us