Skip to main content
Back to Directory

Eric Foner

DeWitt Clinton Professor Emeritus of History, Columbia University

Biography

Eric Foner (born 1943) is an American historian of the Civil War, emancipation, and Reconstruction, and DeWitt Clinton Professor Emeritus of History at Columbia University. He took his B.A. at Columbia in 1963, studied at Oxford as a Kellett Fellow, and returned to Columbia for his doctorate in 1969 under Richard Hofstadter. He has been on Columbia's faculty since 1982.

His first book, Free Soil, Free Labor, Free Men (1970), grew out of that dissertation and traced the free-labor ideas that held the early Republican Party together. Reconstruction: America's Unfinished Revolution, 1863-1877 (1988) became the standard account of the era and won the Bancroft Prize, the Francis Parkman Prize, and the Los Angeles Times Book Prize. Two decades later The Fiery Trial: Abraham Lincoln and American Slavery (2010) took the 2011 Pulitzer Prize for History along with the Lincoln Prize and a second Bancroft.

He is one of only two people to have served as president of all three major professional bodies in the field — the Organization of American Historians, the American Historical Association, and the Society of American Historians. By the Open Syllabus Project's count he is the most frequently assigned author on college history syllabi, largely because of his survey textbook Give Me Liberty! and the document reader Voices of Freedom. He has written for The Nation for decades and has taught a ColumbiaX course on the Civil War and Reconstruction.

What He Changed in the Field

  • Reconstruction, turned right side up: Before the 1960s, standard textbooks taught Reconstruction as a vindictive mistake inflicted on a defeated South. Foner's work, culminating in the 1988 book, showed an era in which freedpeople built churches, schools, and political organizations, and in which that experiment was crushed by violence and northern retreat.
  • The 'unfinished revolution' frame: The book's subtitle became the shorthand teachers use. The era's promises were not simply abandoned — they were never completed, which is why the arguments keep returning.
  • Lincoln as a politician who changed: The Fiery Trial follows Lincoln's thinking on slavery and race as it actually moved, refusing both the marble saint and the cynical operator.
  • Freedom as a contested idea: The Story of American Freedom (1998) traces the arguments Americans have had over what freedom means and, just as important, over who counted as free.
  • The constitutional second founding: The Second Founding (2019) argues that the Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments remade the Constitution and remain the ground under nearly every later rights fight.
  • Public memory as a subject: Who Owns History? (2002) and decades of essays press the question of who gets to shape the national story — and why textbooks, museums, and monuments are fights about power rather than decoration.

Main Ideas

Freedom is an argument, not a fact: There is no single American definition of freedom to hand students. There are competing definitions, each with a social base, and the contest between them is the subject of American history.

Rights are won and can be lost: Emancipation and the Reconstruction amendments were achievements of political struggle, and they were rolled back by organized resistance. Progress is not a ratchet.

Emancipation was a process, not a moment: The Emancipation Proclamation did not end slavery by itself. Freedom arrived unevenly, and freedpeople had to fight for land, labor contracts, schools, and the vote.

The state matters: Foner treats government, law, and constitutional text as real forces — not as a reflection of economic interests — which is why his work is useful in civics classrooms as well as history ones.

History is public memory: How a society remembers the past is itself a political fact. Textbooks, monuments, and museum labels are primary sources about the people who made them.

Documents raise the level of argument: His documentary readers put the evidence in students' hands. The point is not to memorize a verdict but to argue from what survives.

“The United States was not the only nation to experience emancipation in the nineteenth century. Neither plantation slavery nor abolition were unique to the United States. But Reconstruction was.”

— Eric Foner, 'The New View of Reconstruction,' American Heritage (1983)

Selected Books

Our Fragile Freedoms — Essays (2025, W. W. Norton)
The Second Founding — How the Civil War and Reconstruction Remade the Constitution (2019, W. W. Norton)
Battles for Freedom — The Use and Abuse of American History (2017, I. B. Tauris)
Gateway to Freedom — The Hidden History of the Underground Railroad (2015, W. W. Norton)
The Fiery Trial — Abraham Lincoln and American Slavery (2010, W. W. Norton) — Pulitzer Prize for History, Lincoln Prize, Bancroft Prize
Forever Free — The Story of Emancipation and Reconstruction (2005, Knopf, with Joshua Brown)
Give Me Liberty! — An American History (2004, W. W. Norton) — survey textbook
Voices of Freedom — A Documentary History, 2 vols. (2004 and 2008, W. W. Norton) — editor
Who Owns History? — Rethinking the Past in a Changing World (2002, Hill and Wang)
The Story of American Freedom (1998, W. W. Norton)
A Short History of Reconstruction, 1863-1877 (1990) — an abridgement of the 1988 book
Reconstruction — America's Unfinished Revolution, 1863-1877 (1988, Harper and Row) — Bancroft, Parkman, and Los Angeles Times book prizes
Nothing but Freedom — Emancipation and Its Legacy (1983, Louisiana State University Press)
Free Soil, Free Labor, Free Men — The Ideology of the Republican Party Before the Civil War (1970, Oxford University Press)

Criticism and Debate

Continuity versus change: Historians who stress how little changed for freedpeople in daily life argue that 'unfinished revolution' can overstate the break of 1865 to 1877. Foner's answer is that the amendments created tools later generations picked up — which is a claim about possibility, not about results on the ground.
The freedom lens: A reviewer in The New York Review of Books argued that telling the story of American freedom mainly through the experience of Black Americans and women can leave out how most Americans have understood their own freedom. Foner has replied that the test of a society is how it treats the people freedom was easiest to deny.
Present-day politics: Critics on the right say his public writing reads today's fights back into the 1860s. Foner's position is that the past is always studied from somewhere — the honest move is to say where.
Monuments and textbooks: His writing on Confederate monuments drew sharp pushback from heritage groups when he argued the monuments were raised to glorify white supremacy, not simply to record the past.

Why He Matters for Teachers

A teacher who assigns a Foner chapter is handing students an argument, not a verdict. That is the practical gift of his work: he shows how the story of Reconstruction was itself rewritten by later historians, which makes his writing usable for teaching historical thinking and not just content. His survey text and documentary readers are already in circulation in Utah classrooms, and his short public essays are a reliable way to show students how a professional historian makes a case from evidence.

Where to Start for Teachers

The Second Founding (2019) — the shortest entry point. Three amendments, one argument.
The Fiery Trial (2010) — the best single book for a Lincoln or emancipation unit.
A Short History of Reconstruction (1990) — use this with students; the 1988 original is for you.
Forever Free (2005) — illustrated, excellent for building a unit or a museum-style lesson.
'The New View of Reconstruction' (American Heritage, 1983) — a short essay, free online, that is itself a lesson in how history gets rewritten.
Voices of Freedom — primary documents to pair with any of the above.

Support Our Research

Help us continue providing high-quality resources for educators worldwide.

Contact Us